As the NFL season marches on, one question looming over Pittsburgh has nothing to do with strategy, standings, or Super Bowl aspirations—it’s about sentiment. When Kenny Pickett returns to Acrisure Stadium, not as the Steelers’ starting quarterback but as an opponent, how will the fans who once cheered his name greet him?
Former Steelers legend Ben Roethlisberger has weighed in on the matter, stirring the pot with a simple but poignant question: Will Steelers fans cheer or boo Kenny Pickett when he steps onto the field in Pittsburgh?
Pickett’s time in Pittsburgh was a rollercoaster. Drafted in the first round in 2022, the hometown hero and University of Pittsburgh alum was initially seen as the heir apparent to Roethlisberger. But after two inconsistent seasons and a mix of injuries and offensive struggles, Pickett was traded to the Philadelphia Eagles in a stunning offseason move. Now, with a fresh start across the state, his return to Pittsburgh carries an emotional weight for fans and the franchise alike.
Roethlisberger, no stranger to the ups and downs of the Steel City spotlight, expressed curiosity about how Pickett will be received. “It’ll be very telling,” Roethlisberger said on his podcast. “This fanbase is passionate. They don’t forget. But they also recognize effort—and disappointment.”
So, what should fans feel?
On one hand, Pickett never quite met the lofty expectations placed on his shoulders. His stats were modest, his development uneven. Some fans believe he was given ample opportunity and simply didn’t seize it. On the other hand, Pickett gave his all for the team he grew up dreaming of leading. He brought heart, poise, and a deep connection to the city, even if it didn’t translate to long-term success on the field.
The return of a former quarterback is always a test of memory versus emotion, performance versus personality. Will fans see Pickett as the quarterback who fell short or as the young leader who did his best in a difficult situation?
Perhaps Roethlisberger’s question is less about Pickett and more about Steelers Nation itself. It’s a reflection of what kind of fanbase Pittsburgh wants to be—one that honors loyalty and effort, or one that judges purely by the box score.
When Pickett steps back onto the grass of Acrisure Stadium, he won’t just be facing the Steelers defense. He’ll be facing the verdict of a city that once believed he was their future.
And in that moment, the reaction from the stands may say more about the fans than it does about the man they’re reacting to.
Leave a Reply