After a rollercoaster 2024-25 campaign, the New York Rangers may soon face a pivotal decision regarding former No. 1 overall pick Alexis Lafrenière. Despite showing flashes of the offensive upside that once made him the face of the franchise’s rebuild, Lafrenière’s recent step back in production — finishing the season with just 17 goals and 45 points — has reignited speculation that he could be a centerpiece in an offseason trade.
With a new seven-year, $52.15 million contract ($7.45 million AAV) set to begin next season, the Rangers must weigh whether Lafrenière is a long-term core piece or if his value is better leveraged in a deal to reshape their roster. While the 2023-24 season saw Lafrenière post a career-best 28 goals, this past year’s regression raises real concerns about his trajectory.
To be fair, his linemates Artemi Panarin and Vincent Trocheck also saw declines, suggesting systemic issues rather than individual failure. But Lafrenière’s inability to assert himself as a star has sparked voices — including that of New York Post’s Mollie Walker — suggesting the Rangers might benefit by moving on sooner rather than later.
Let’s dive into one particularly compelling trade idea — and a few other realistic targets — should GM Chris Drury entertain the notion of parting ways with Lafrenière.
1. Anaheim Ducks: Trevor Zegras for Lafrenière – A High-Risk, High-Reward Swap
The most headline-grabbing potential return? Anaheim’s Trevor Zegras.
Once heralded as the future of the Ducks’ offense, Zegras has endured two injury-riddled campaigns that have disrupted his momentum. However, the 23-year-old remains an electric talent with elite playmaking skills and a highlight-reel presence. He notched back-to-back 60-point seasons as a 20- and 21-year-old before injuries curtailed his recent output.
A one-for-one swap of Lafrenière for Zegras might not be enough to satisfy Anaheim, especially considering Zegras’ higher offensive ceiling. But if the Rangers are willing to include a draft pick or a mid-tier prospect, there’s a path to a blockbuster deal that benefits both sides. For New York, Zegras could inject creativity and flair into a lineup that often looked stale in 2024-25.
2. Ottawa Senators: Shane Pinto
Pinto, a two-way center who brings structure and secondary scoring, could be a logical target if the Rangers look for more balance down the middle. Ottawa may be open to moving him if they continue reshaping their roster under a new front office direction.
While Pinto doesn’t offer the same flash as Zegras, he fits the mold of a reliable, versatile forward who could thrive in Peter Laviolette’s system. A Lafrenière-for-Pinto deal could benefit both clubs — giving Ottawa a potential top-six winger with upside, and giving New York a center with cost control and defensive responsibility.
3. Columbus Blue Jackets: Kent Johnson
If the Rangers are interested in a younger player who still possesses untapped upside, Kent Johnson could be an intriguing target. The Blue Jackets, flush with forward prospects, might be willing to part with Johnson if they believe Lafrenière offers more proven NHL experience.
Johnson, like Lafrenière, has had an uneven start to his career, but his skill and hockey sense remain enticing. A change of scenery might do both players good.
4. Nashville Predators: Philip Tomasino
The Predators have shown an openness to retooling on the fly, and a Lafrenière-for-Tomasino swap could represent a fresh start for two players who have yet to fully meet expectations. Tomasino has struggled to carve out a consistent role in Nashville’s lineup, but his speed and offensive instincts could make him a breakout candidate in a more aggressive system.
For New York, this would be a bet on potential — similar to the way they once viewed Lafrenière.
Conclusion: Time to Turn the Page or Stay the Course?
There’s no question Alexis Lafrenière still has value — he’s just 23, has flashed top-line potential, and is entering the prime years of his career. But if the Rangers believe their current core has plateaued, shopping Lafrenière could be the most impactful move they make this offseason.
Trevor Zegras might be the boldest play, but there are several viable options across the league that could help New York reset their mix. Whether Drury pulls the trigger remains to be seen, but the clock is ticking on what was once the most hyped prospect in recent memory.
Leave a Reply